Culture Must Change to Support Policy Initiatives to Reduce Mass Shootings

      Some years ago I was at an U12 soccer tournament in an upscale Southern New England town. One squad worked through pregame warmups in tony outfits with a warning for opponents printed on their backs: “We work our butts off so we can kick yours.” A TV sitcom aired an episode with two young women sharing a lunch break. One abruptly announced she had to go because someone in her office is getting fired. Her friend asked, “Why do you have to go?” “Because I’m the one doing the firing!” she answered, all smiles and giggles. In a TV news feature, a group of new principals was interviewed. One was asked how it felt to be appointed: “powerful!” she said, as if she just ingested a large can of educational spinach a la Popeye. Before interstate banking was normalized, a New York City based financial institution told a corporate division it was moving big time into smaller western states despite local resistance. The speaker challenged the states and local banks to sue them bec “we’d bankrupt them if they tried,” sounding more like Dillinger than Rockefeller.

Now-candidate Donald Trump told his followers earlier this month:

In 2016 I declared I am your voice. Today I add: I am your warrior. I am your justice. And for those who have been wronged and betrayed—I am your retribution.” I am your retribution.” Godhood personified.

What common thread connects these disparate tableaus of Americana? The power imperative. In American secular society, power sits upon its podium, worshipped, desired, coveted. It’s what we mean when asked, “What you do for a living?” The inquirer isn’t being sociable or showing interest, the question is a probe to discern the pecking order. The euphemistic question really asks how much wealth you have compared to me. Only the ones with money and the aura of power it emits ask the question. Cab drivers and waiters and data processors don’t ask because they lack the economic power and its social prestige to win. Know your enemy.        

In feminist language, words have changed to neutralize what they view as male dominance. History becomes herstory (even though the word has no gender relevance). “Women” becomes the emasculated ‘womyn”. However, the word “manager” has never been amended for gender language because it connotes a woman executive having power over individuals—especially men. E Pluribus Unum may be our nation’s motto, but it lives by Leo Durocher’s “Nice guys finish last.” 

The power imperative describes the realms we want to rule: socio-economic, personal relationships, work and career, the internal power of self-actualization. None of these are necessarily evil or wrong. However, the moral compass breaks as we aspire to dominate, to be a winner at all costs. It’s not how you play the game, it’s that you win. It’s about the cruelty. Trumpworld rejoicing in the suffering of those they hate and fear   (Adam Serwer, The Atlantic, Oct 3, 2018).   

We worship the material success, the money makers, the fabulously popular, the celebrity. Reality television means anyone can be a star, and we live vicariously through the neighbor next door surviving the jungle, the singer from Noplace bowing to a standing ovation when last month she was a waitress on Main street, now sipping cocktails at a penthouse party, all shining brightly on tv as we whisper to ourselves ”I could be that person”.

No place has ever personified Nietzsche’s will to power as the American way of life. “Only Americans can make birding a competition”, said a British birder watching the frenetic intensity to be number 1 in the film The Big Year. Donald Trump’s The Apprentice made the words “You’re fired!” part of our cultural argot, as we all shouted collectively at the victim. In 2006 Time magazine put a mirror on its cover and proclaimed “You” its recipient for “Person of the Year” Award. Now anyone can look into the Time’s mirror and see in his/her reflection a rarified individual of historic proportions. It feeds the ego with empty accomplishment and faux superiority, just like the Disneyworld magazine covers you buy with your face pictured under Best___________ of the Year (choose your sport or alter ego).

Own the libs. So we can kick your butt. Cancel culture. You’re fired!        Master–slave. The Powerful—the powerless. 

If you  have no girlfriend, no money, students shun you in class, bullies seem to be everywhere against you. In the adult world you’ve lost things dear to you, or you obsess over a world not spinning to your Weltanschauung; everyday nothing changes except your deepening desperation. What do you do in a society so permeated by the climb to to the top when you’re the bottom rung of anonymity and rejection.

You buy the great equalizer. Several of them. Pistols and assault rifles, flack jackets and SWAT gear. The great American Ninja  Warrior dressed to kill, and ready to die in a blaze of divine fire and hellish glory. You’ve transcended the quiet life of desperation, of faceless living staring at the smirks and picking up the barely audible whispers loud enough for you to hear, turning into giggles behind your back. Persecution at every turn. But your  AR-15,or AK-47, plus a sidearm or two—Congratulations! You’ve made it. You are now God, the ultimate authority of Life and Death. You have attained the American dream.

The divine impulse, the imperative to power, permeates the mind of the mass shooters consistently. Columbine shooter Eric Harris in is writings “I am the law; if you don’t like it you die” His partner Dylan Klebold wrote that he found true love and made him “infinite times greater than the wealthy and powerful…I want to die sooo bad…such a sad, desolate, lonely, unsalvageable life, The god of sadness.”

“I understand everything. I am the god of everything.” declared Sandy Hook mass killer, Adam Lanza. He had a history of mental and emotional problems documented from early on. Socially dysfunctional, developmental problems, the killer of 26 in an elementary school warned us. We just didn’t pay attention. Anxiety. Asperger’s. OCD. A walking Pearl Harbor the radar spotted but excused. Seung Hui Cho, who killed over 30 people on the campus of Virginia Tech, wrote: You had a 100 billion chances to avoid this day. But you forced me into a corner.” He said to MSNBC (from CNN) “You had everything. Your Mercedes wasn’t enough, you brats, Your golden necklaces weren’t enough, you snobs.” His mental illness was known; students feared him. A judge declared him mentally ill and an imminent danger--two years before the shooting. Nicholas Cruz, the infamous gunman responsible for the Marjorie Douglas Stoneham High School massacre, known as Parkland, chose St Valentine’s Day to kill 17 people because no one loved him and wanted to ruin the holiday for the entire school (AP).  Even adults like 64 year-old Stephen Paddock, the Las Vegas sniper who killed almost 60 concert goers at Mandalay Bay, felt alone, that God didn’t love him. His brother said he was bored with life and capable of an act to commit mass murder for the price of fame and glory; he took control of a life spinning out of it. (CBS News)

Power to the Powerless. I am God.

Or, as someone else said 25 years later, “I am your retribution.”. I am God.

Serbia recently suffered two major gun attacks within two days. One in a school by a 13 year-old student, and another by a young man aged 20 who shot up two villages. Both incidents accounted for nearly 20 people killed and others wounded.

Despite having a high rate of gun ownership, apparently the weapons were leftover from the Balkan wars in the 1990s. Apparently the peace left  people awash with firearms. Yet,  these were the first mass shootings since 2013—10 years ago. The Balkan war was long over.

What makes America different than Serbia, than the rest of the world when it comes to guns? The answer lies in the culture, in our values, how we live and work and play. Our super aggressive culture, our extreme tough-guy, ego driven socio-economic values obsession with celebrity and wealth and popularity, with winners and losers and fend-for-yourself attitude could only lead inevitably to the forsaken collateral damage seeking not merely parity but victory and subjugation of the tormentors. No one wants to lose.

Thor had his hammer, Poseidon his trident, Zeus his thunder, God his omnipotence, Americans their guns. The ultimate judgment of a god—who shall live and who shall die. Nothing speaks to power more than deciding life or death. To steal Valentine’s day from the innocent. I am my retribution.

We do not have to take away all guns, there is a legitimate argument for recreation, such as skeet shooting and hunting,  but we must knock it from the pedestal. Let it fall like a defeated deity’s oversized statue. In the latest shooting, in Allen, Texas, a six-year old is orphaned, a family wiped out; two young siblings obliterated by an AR-15’s massive damage. Gun violence is now the number one killer of children. Grotesquely, we have Congressmen wearing lapel pins to make it the national gun. I am your god.

 On a pragmatic level, we must commit to the reparations of heart and soul, mind and health, from the time we identify at-risk individuals at any age and follow up with a multi-agency response across appropriate government and private services. Vigilance, purpose and dedication armed with continual monitoring, meaningful action, customized treatment focusing on bringing the individual back to the fold of humanity before pulling a trigger. The price is high, the cost of not doing is dead kids, murdered teachers, innocents from every age and category of life, in schools, malls, concerts—no place is safe. I am my retribution.

 Nothing will be enough until a collective America finds the fault in itself. We have a gun problem driven by our values problem. Pope John II, looking to America, said capitalism needs a human face. President George H. Bush asked for a kinder, gentler nation. If our contagious mass murders are rooted in emotional and mental health, Uncle Sam needs to look in the mirror and ask himself how much carnage results from his own out-of-control concepts of wealth, greed, power, callousness, politics, fanaticism, ego.

When guns no longer represent the killer’s self-anointed, god-like supremacy on a sacred mission to vanquish his demons, be it a personal grievance or a political belief, America will finally have the gunslayers’ scourge of  mass murder at school, at work, at play in its cross hairs.  

BEELINES

Thursday, June 1, 2023. As the underpinnings of our government and society seem to be unraveling, the longstanding respect for sportsmanship also has gone out of bounds. Parents and athletes both have shown an unhinged willingness to attack the referees, the coaches, the other teams, each other. It is a metaphor for our times…The Republican Party, long the self-proclaimed party of family rights and minimal government interference in our day-to-day lives, has declared war on family decision making and young people. The entire LGBTQ community, pregnant women, Holocaust studies, entertainment decisions, child labor laws—even the country itself by kidnapping the debt ceiling and demanding ransom-- all under a fusillade by an increasingly authoritarian, reactionary unhinged GOP…Not to be outdone, the national; socialist Democrats, led by Tlaib the Terrible, staunch Israelophobic and Palestinian jihadist, held a Nakba event in the Capitol Building. This get-together was an orgy of Jewhatred never seen in Congress. While Speaker McCarthy denied them the public flogging of the world’s only Jewish majority state, the Squad’s pet Jew, Sen Sanders, rushed to their rescue, finding a Senate room for them, thereby giving the event an ersatz patina of respectability…Now that a deb celling deal has been reached, I can’t say I’m not disappointed President Biden did not invoke the 14th Amendment. It would’ve have vitiated budget terrorism forever. It would ‘ve backed into a corner all the strict constructionists” who say do what the Constitution says the way it was written. “The validity of the public debt…shall not be questioned.” It would force these mostly hard right wingers to decide on their oft-invoked principle or their politics. Would’ve been fun.

 Tuesday, April 25,2023. According to news media and a UN report, over 500 children have been killed in the Russian attack on Ukraine. Defectors from the Wagner Group, the mercenary outfit supplying thugs for Putin’s wet dream, have confessed to executing about forty of threm. Europe hasn’t seen such savagery since the Third Reich…Russia has also transported Ukrainian children to Russia for repatriation. The sadistic nature of such a policy recalls the cruelty of Trump-era kidnapping and family demolition at the US southern border.  As of Feb 2023, nearly 1,000 kids are still separated from their families, according to Reuters…A shocking study by the CDC sounds the alarm on the deteriorating mental and emotional health of our young people. To Democrats and Republicans, I’ll repeat law officer Jim Malone’s mantra to Eliot Ness in The Untouchables: “What are you prepared to do!?”…As George Santos (R-NY) sports an AR-15 lapel pin advocating it be named the country’s national gun, I have only one question for the voters of New York’s 3rd Congressional District: “What are you prepared to do?”

Wednesday, Mar 22, 2023…A new competition is on among the Red states. Which self-proclaimed but misnomered “pro-life” government will be the first to execute a 16-year-old girl for aborting a pregnancy, a proposal being led by South Carolina…Ron DeSantis and his state GOP now want bloggers located in Florida who write about politics register with his regime. The mere suggestion reeks of Nazi Germany’s Reichskulturkammer, to which all writers and artists were obligated to join. The price of admission was your Nazi Party membership card; to maintain your good standing professionally, you had to toe the party line. Given the Governor’s other repressive measures, I wonder where democracy would go under a Chancellor--oops--President DeSantis…Speaking of Florida, Republican legislator Stan McClain is sponsoring a bill to prohibit talk of menstruation in schools until 6th grade, along with other restrictions on sexuality topics. I now understand what Governor DeS means by the Free State of Florida free from gays, free from books, free from medical defenses against disease, free from women’s health services, and free from menstruation before the age of 12. Perhaps we will see some Red state legislator write a bill making that illegal. Violations would be punishable by death for any girl who has her period before 6th grade.The Sunshine State and the Palmetto State race neck-and-neck to the finish line of history: Which will be the first one to hang a teenage girl for an abortion next to her fifth grade sister for menstruating. Does the TGBL blog now have to register in Florida? I guess Florida is free from the First Amendment too…The New York Post quoted the Staten Island DA Michael McMahon on a recent spate of student shootings and stabbings, offering his view on why: ” …bad laws and young people who are disconnected from responsible behavior”. While that’s not the whole picture, McMahon’s dart is close to the bullseye. The progressives’ au courant negative discipline over the last ten years has given rise to a cottage industry around restorative justice, education lawyers, consultants , counselors, comp jobs, and ersatz therapy sessions. Everybody’s a winner--except the victims of school crime.   

Wednesday, March 8,2023: After an extended absence, it’s good to be back writing on the myriad issues affecting our kids and our kids at school. I look forward to a more regular posting of new commentary, dollops and stingers, the daily beelines, and other additions from the educational underground. TGBL will also have eyes on international education impacting the health of the world’s young…I’m still trying to see how Gov De Santis’ war on Disney World upholds conservative values, considering his rants about government overreach against Covid mandates in a pubic health emergency, who now punishes a private business for internal policies. Are we witnessing the end of the Republican conservativism and the birth of a  mutated party?...The GOP movement taking aim at naming the AR-15 assault rifle as the national gun manifests irresponsibility as lawmakers and, as people, contempt for adults and kids killed by the hands of active shooters—especially school mass murderers whose weapon of choice is the made-for-war assault rifle AR-15--also the principle weapon in the 2017 attack in Las Vegas, killing 58 people…Bowdlerizing Roald Dahl’s works for more acceptable sensibilities violates the first amendment and attacks free expression. It is no different than the Popes or John Ashcroft covering the private parts of public statuary. The Left and the Right meet again, to everyone’s detriment. TGL will explore this issue more fully later this month… One of the worst commercials appearing in the last year was a mom slinking down in her Infiniti, shutting her window to block out a school orchestra’s cacophony of 2001 A Space Odyssey’s famous opening. Besides selling a car to moms who can’t stand listening to a kids’ concert, we now have a car company ad modeling today’s parenting technique…give ‘em hell, mommy!

  September 1, 2021. Texas district suffered two teachers’ deaths by COVID. They taught at the same school. All five campuses in the district now shut down. Can someone please talk sense into the Texas state government, or have they lost their minds totally?… North Carolina suffered two school shootings in one week in this nascent year. While not many details have emerged from both incidents, The first shooting victim will survive; the second died from his wounds. It is not just gun control, it is the gun culture. We will have more such incidents, as we are up to 14 for the year… and counting. August 17, 2021. From now on, the first person “I” shall be used much more frequently instead of the third person eponymous Green B Letter or TGBL. While a rule of journalism says op/ed pieces should use first person, internet standards allow blogs and websites to use either one. So, I’m going with first person singular but will synonymously  interject TGBL a time or two…TGBL is not ready to award any dollops to Kentucky Senator  Mitch McConnell, but his urging Covid vaccinations, backed by his personal history of polio, can only be praised and applauded. Late to the party, but welcome nonetheless…New York state has sent a bill to Gov. Cuomo banning child marriage. You will have to be 18 to tie the knot, eliminating the judge’s power to consent for a 17 year-old. Having experienced firsthand the anguish of a middle-school girl already promised to wed a mature man, such protection cannot arrive any sooner. Congrats to NYS, which ended permission for even younger girls to marry several years ago…Whatever happened to protecting the health and welfare of the children as our first priority? Supporters of the COVID19 pandemic has no problem throwing children on the altar of political sacrifice. So much for family values.             

 August 2, 2021. From now on, the first person “I” shall be used much more frequently instead of the third person eponymous Green B Letter or TGBL. While a rule of journalism says op/ed pieces should use first person, internet standards allow blogs and websites to use either one. So, I’m going with first person singular but will synonymously  interject TGBL a time or two…TGBL (told you) is not ready to award any dollops to Kentucky senator Moscow Mitch McConnell, but his urging Covid vaccinations, backed by his personal history of polio, can only be praised and applauded. Late to the party, but welcome nonetheless…New York state has sent a bill to Gov. Cuomo banning child marriage. You will have to be 18 to tie the knot, eliminating the judge’s power to consent for a 17 year-old. Having experienced first hand the anguish of a middle-school girl already promised to wed a mature man, such protection cannot arrive any sooner. Congrats to NYS, which ended permission for even younger girls to marry several years ago…Showmatch, an Argentine TV talent show, used Anne Frank’s picture as a background for a song about women who don’t want to stay home but seek worldy pursuits. Exploiting a murdered girl from one of the history’s greatest crimes for a snicker or two manifests bad judgment and awful taste. It only reinforces antiJewish attitudes and mocks the Holocaust. Perhaps that was the intent, maybe not. But they could have used a Black slave too, but didn’t. Not that that would be any better, but one can’t help but feel a callous disregard. At least an apology by the producers was offered, admitting a terrible mistake. I believe in a full and robust freedom of speech, but that also includes a responsibility for how you use it. Hopefully, lesson learned.

 June 7, 2021. Covid-19 took no adolescent lives from Jan 1- Mar 31, which is great news. However, a recent uptick of cases in young people, including the need for ICU beds and ventilators, has some medical and scientific professionals worried. Mask wearing, distancing and increased vaccinations—the troika of right wing (and some left anti-vaxxers) efforts to thwart recovery from the disease—must continue for us to beat down COVID-19, as we have been doing…A concern has arisen regarding giving the vaccines to teens in which tissues around the heart become enflamed, a rare cardiac occurrence. Evidence says the statistics are normal for the appearance of the rare affliction, and nothing suggests a nexus to vaccines in kids. Experts will be monitoring nonetheless.  Given the deaths of hundreds of children and hospitalization of thousands, it would seem contracting COVID is far worse than what appears a non-existent risk from the vaccine.

June 1, 2021. COVID-19 took a toll not only on our lives, but the way we live them. Routines broken, relationships separated, quarantine and isolation, alone or with family. huddled together as our caves offered shelter from the threatening outside, a virus shelter wed prayed would be invasion-proof. Responsibilities took new and difficult turns, even for those who escaped infection. TGBL once again had to suspend operations as more immediate and personal needs took precedence. Right now, we give one glance in the rearview mirror reflecting the path driven. With the past year retreating, it is eyes forward, as we step on the back-to-business pedal and accelerate down the bumpy, mine-filled roads ahead. Hold onto your hats.

Feb. 11 2021. Still cannot find the right balance or formula to resume schooling and high-risk athletics, though many school districts are expanding their varsity sports…Las Vegas teen suicides spiked so high that Clark County opened up its doors earlier than expected as the isolation and lack of normalcy were cited as major contributing factors…Conservatives, and frustrated liberal parents who actually have to raise their own kids blame teachers and their unions for delaying full school openings due to health concerns, labeling them fraidy cats and imperious as others face work-related COVID hazards without bitchin’. What a terrible thing of these teachers to expect high standards of protection against a pandemic that has cost 500,000 lives in the US. Most schools, especially urban ones have poor ventilation broken windows, and kids who will deliberately spit on door handles or people these days yelling “COVID!” at the target. Schools are not you’re your typical business office...Rochester, NY police cuffed and pepper sprayed what appeared to be  a nine year old girl in a violent fit whose threats of suicide and killing her mother prompted calls to the police in the first place. If you don’t want such incidents repeated, don’t call the police--have a special team of pediatric mental health workers who respond to acute crises of out of control, suicidal, matricidal threatening children or adults in similar cases of mentally disturbed people. Only teachers and others who work with all kinds of children know the injury and risk children pose in the midst of a rage. Before the two RPD heads roll, maybe Rochester and other cities ought to think about how they want to handle these situations going forward. We’re sure RPD would love to hand this off to professionals in juvenile mental heath. Scapegoating two officers for bad optics in a scenario they were ill-prepared for is an injustice and costs the city two officers with ruined careers. Lost in all the mess is the fact that the girl was unhurt and the mother wasn’t killed, the possibilities of which were why the cops were there…The Long Island Grinch Who stole the post-holiday spirit deserves the Bronx Cheer. The perp sent out letters to a family who continued to display Christmas decorations to honor two relatives who died of COVID. “Take down your Christmas decorations. It’s Valentine’s Day!” read the note. Maybe we need to change the biblical “We are our brother’s keeper” to “Everybody is everybody else’s boss.” The community is rallying around the aggrieved neighbor. Let’s have a thousand points of light!

JAN. 28, 2021. MIS-C in children has often flown under the radar, mostly because its numbers are not high compared to the general COVID devastation. However, the virus’ numbers are rising among kids: 350,000 cases, 7 deaths in CAL; Omaha, NB’s Children’s Hospital and Medical Center  reports largest number of COVID related MIS-C cases, several of whom had to go on heart-lung machines. Other states report similar situations…It will be very interesting to see how school curricula teaches about Jan 6, now taking its place next to April 12, 1865, Dec. 7, 1941, and Sept. 11, 2001 as the most heinous dates in American history…Rep. Marjorie Taylor Green, our first Congresswoman to represent both a district in the United States (R-GA) and a planet in an alternate universe. Her belief that the massacre of 17 in Parkwood was a false flag and Sandy Hook’s 26 dead was staged were found on her Twitter account. As far as TGBL knows, it was expressed in English and not in her native tongue, originating somewhere in the Horsehead Nebula. We can only hope her brain cells recover because if such stupidity votes on vital matters of life and death, war and peace, we can only paraphrase Shakespeare: if more be brained like her, the state totters…Washington Post did a story on the need for civility and etiquette’s return to travel, especially in the on-edge pandemic age: “Travelers should be patient, civil, and courteous to each other”. Geez, how un-American can you get?

Dec 15 to Jan. 8, 2021. Happy New Year to All! TGBL’s extended time off is over and now its back to work…In Texas an 18 year old football player—who is also a wrestling star—got thrown out of a game for a cheap shot on an opponent. He walks to the sideline and then sprints across the field, blindsiding the 58 yr old referee sent flying to the turf. In NYC two dozen bicyclists stopped traffic and began to beat up a BMW as the occupants feared for their lives. We are firmly convinced the underlying cause of such incidents relates to the evisceration of true character building through acceptance of one’s responsibility for his or her own actions through effective school discipline. TGBL bets the farm that no study will be done to ascertain a nexus between adolescent anti-social oppositional activity and the end of real consequences for poor school behavior. Teachers and other school community members experience it every day, and now innocent citizens get their own taste of kids gone wild…Earlier in the year a dean at New York City’s CUNY Law School upheld the right to immolate a student because, according to her, lighting up a fellow student falls within free speech. More on this in a future issue of the Green B Letter…Dr. Nahid Bhadelina.an infectious disease expert said “our health care system is facing collapse” given the number of patients for whom doctors must make life-and-death decisions that must be made in hospitals overtaken by a viral tsunami…Children are more susceptible to the new mutant COVID strain recently discovered. While not more lethal but more contagious, this means more kids getting COOVID will result in more once-healthy kids suffering from MIS-C –multiple system inflammatory syndrome. How many politicians who were killing off your grandparents to fully open their states and cities will now demand we sacrifice kids for the greater good? Assemble at the public square and bring your swaddled. COVID has exposed our health care system as pathetically behind in affordable care and mass epidemic preparation. We need to get away from work-based insurance and for-profit HMOs.

An old radio host used to sign off: “Your influence counts--use it! A lesson learned by the Big  Med –Political--Economic complex…Stay safe.

Dec 5 -12 2020: Good news on one front: Vaping among teens, especially middle schoolers, is way down. Let’s hope the trend continues…Put aside the vast seriousness of the situation for just a moment and admit the Queens street fight between Cuomo and Trump rivals the climax of “Enter the Dragon” as Lee and Norris duke it out in the Roman Colosseum …Wayne Sebastianelli, from CNN, reports Penn State Univ Director of Athletic Medicine, said 30-35% of all Covid-19 positive athletes had an inflamed heart. If you want college football and basketball, tell your leaders to fix the problem instead of trying to sacrifice the players’ health and lives for their own political advantage.

Can Pres Trump stop his war on America? If he knew what he was doing and cared for anyone but himself, America’s economy and cities would be in a much better economic position. Trump’s threat to withhold        federal funds just adds to destabilizing America and punishing people whom he perceives are against him. He not only rejects the idea of being a president for all the people, he actively seeks their harm as sacrifices to his re-election. TGBL finds this an unmitigated attack on families and children, who are suffering enough in this health emergency. The president awaits the mantle of a Stalin, a Mao, a Pol Pot. Of course, he wouldn’t even know who Pol Pot was…Teachers, especially in New York, have received a fair amount of criticism for their push back via union leadership about opening the schools. NYC finally decided to delay the opening too late September. What the critics need to understand is that nothing in the NYC Department of Education goes according to plan, nor do they do what is promised. When teachers hear the DOE will do everything necessary to keep them safe, the skepticism remains high – ventilation, air conditioning, social distancing—even the city recognizes they were not ready to open…22 teachers have tested positive, and that’s without the kids. College Administrations fret like parents as the students party till dawn and face Covid-19 rather than mere hangovers. SUNY Oneonta, NYU, Univ of Iowa among others across the country are either shutting down,  going strictly online, or the admins are laying on the floor in a fetal position with their thumbs deeply planted in their mouths.     

WEDNESDAY, AUG. 19, 2020: Gov Andrew Cuomo, a speaker at the DNC virtual convention, was asked if he felt any pressure from his father, the late Gov Mario Cuomo whose 1984 speech at the Democratic get-together still resonates 35 years later. “Do I feel pressure from my father’s legacy? Everyday!”, he responded. A nice personal confession so many sons of far less famous fathers feel…Postmaster General DeJoy suspended “reforms” until after the election. The outcry and outrage of sabotaging the mail delivery sent shivers through American spines that always stood tall and strong for American loyalty and values. Not only were the changes premeditated attempts to disrupt our elections, but our people rely on the USPS for medicine, checks, goods from stores and family, important information and documents, just about anything. They are stamped not only with postage, but with reassurance and relief that in these times no matter what, the mail will go through. Families’ disrupted lives are now hard enough under the pandemic, and those precious pieces of mail help households stay sane. Whoever thought that Costner’s film “The Postman”, a forgettable concoction centering on a letter carrier and the mail, would suddenly emanate prescience.   

 

Toronto Uber Alles?

For Canadian Jews, especially those in Toronto, O Canada’s “The True North strong and free” is less a line from the national anthem than a close cousin to Arbeit Macht Frei, the Nazi slogan on the entrance gates to the concentration camps. The Queen City has rapidly eclipsed other worthy candidates for the most antisemitic metropolis on the continent.

Ubiquitous signs saying “No Jews or dogs allowed” commonly appeared at beaches, parks, resorts and other recreation facilities”. (Levit, Toronto Star) regularly appeared dating back decades.
No group has been hurt more by Toronto’s pervasive Jewhatred than students and teachers. Temerty Faculty of Medicine U of T’s medical school is rife with anti-Semitism, apparently an old tradition emanating from its entrance quota for Jews. The university’s Student Union tried to block kosher food from being sold on campus because customers might be Israel supporters. Jewish, in other words. The Toronto District School Board has experienced a rash of ominous incidents in their buildings. Students disturbing class by offering a Nazi salute to a Jewish teacher. The list of bigoted acts can go on and on. In educational facilities or city streets, or any venue such vitriol can find ground to attack. In a city with a large Jewish population, Toronto’s antiSemitism seems more popular than Hockey Night in Canada.  

The municipal government has initiated A “Toronto for All” program to fight prejudice, including Jewhatred, despite the dispersion of focus such a title connotes when Jews have been the main target. There has been a somewhat milquetoast Working Group on Antisemitism at the University of Toronto for several years. TDSB claims it will enrich Holocaust learning to promote understanding and respect for Jewish classmates, teachers and others in the community.

Time will tell if these measures prove effective. If the culture doesn’t believe, refuses to change, attacks Jews for religious or political aims, all the enlightenment will not let willfully blind eyes see.

 Normally, TGBL awards stingers for bad behavior. We’ll use an alternative opprobrium for this one—and future issues. We’ll be watching Ontario’s capital for progress in the safety of Jewish and pro-democratic Israel individuals in the K-college level, as well as Toronto holding guilty parties accountable. For now, judgment at Toronto hass been passed::

Heute geben wir Toronto zwei Hakenkreuze. (Today we give Toronto two swastikas.)

Gun Violence Will Still Have Students in the Crosshairs in 2023

 With 2023 two months old, news came down from Virginia of a horrific school shooting. A six-year-old brought his mom’s gun to school and shot his teacher, nearly killing her. Then Michigan State University: 3 dead, five injured. Seven K-12 school shootings resulting in injury or death through Feb 26. History has taught us that this will not be the last use of a gun in a school, nor the end of targeting teachers.

Violence will continue to plague our K-12, Higher Ed campuses throughout the year. According to the Washington Post, 338,000 students have been exposed to armed violence at school since 1999. Gun-level events are the most lethal but rarest manifestation of school insecurity. Every day, kids and staff are subjected to mental, emotional, and physical threats and attacks from multiple fronts.  

In-person. Online social media. Phones. The daily tribulations of anti-social, oppositional—even criminal--behavior, impede educational progress, and harm the school environment. One incident in one classroom or hallway can reverberate schoolwide. The disrespect, the threats, the shakedowns, the stabbings, the thefts, the assaults, the bullying all sit simmering on the back burner as the left and right fight it out over gun control. Progressives and liberals believe gun control will make schools safe, but then advocate and implement negative discipline policies indifferent to victims of daily serious misbehaviors. Sympathizing with the perpetrators who victimize individuals and even an entire school only encourage violent acts. Conservatives support harder discipline for safety infractions and other forms of school discipline violations, yet they fight tooth-and-nail gun reforms that potentially would mitigate the frequency and severity of active shooters on school campuses.

 We need to cleave off the gun control of the Left and the stronger discipline of the Right; add comprehensive interagency cooperation  among law enforcement, mental and other social services, with new  approaches for proactive monitoring and early intervention, we just might gain control of the scourge mass shootings and school assaults represent. The two present a dangerous synergy producing thousands of physical and mental casualties in schools. We have not addressed the problem effectively.   

There is some shared ground, but don’t expect terre firma walking it.The Left and Right both see a shooter’s mental, emotional status as significant. That’s where it ends. The conservatives close their eyes to the reality that most perps arm themselves with an inventory close to a small country. I guess they’re okay with unstable, volatile Rambos possessing such firepower. The Left believes strongly in mental services and gun control—a good start. They also want to defund law and get PDs, SROs out of schools, leaving them defenseless and attack-friendly, from intruders to cafeteria riots. Uvalde and Parkwood were law enforcement failure, but if the lesson learned is the Left’s police and security purge for guidance counselors and therapy sessions, or the Right’s arming teachers, remedial help in understanding the subject is needed.

One more thing. More important than legislation, more powerful than an impassioned speech, more transforming than alchemy, more difficult to change than a closed mind. But reducing school and campus  gun deaths and other violent acts won’t happen without it. An upcoming Green B Letter feature will tell you what’s missing from the gun debate, so vital to school safety.

Gov. DeSantis' Most Dangerous Gayme

Bad enough DeSantis bullied teens into not wearing masks because he was afraid the optics would upset the anti-vaxxer, anti-mask, pro-Covid Trumplicans he’s trying to pull into his corner for a 2024 presidential run. Now he’s putting more than 100,000 Floridians under 18 years of age in jeopardy. That’s an estimate of the number of LGBTQ+ youths who live in Florida, attending school, playing sports, working part time, worrying about college, figuring out life in the Sunshine state.

The infamous and euphemistically named Parental Rights in Education Act  should have been called “Let’s Make Life Harder and Riskier for Our Young Gay People”. These kids—10% of any population fit into the LGBTQ umbrella, closeted or not—suffer higher rates in the following: suicidal thoughts and attempts, alcoholism and drug abuse, depression, victims of  bullying, mental and emotional issues. For many, tween and teen years mean a daily struggle to get through the day.

Across the country, many school districts attempt to reduce attacks on LGBTQ+ by promoting a positive environment. This includes developing trust between students and staff, maintain counseling and open communications, and programs promoting respect and tolerance.  Sexual minority students feel more positive about themselves and do better overall in a nonjudgmental, supportive school climate. Many Florida districts openly proclaim this goal in statements found in their  codes of conduct.

Florida’s Polk County Board pledges to “vigorously enforce its           prohibition against harassment based on race, color, national origin, sex (including sexual orientation, transgender status or gender identity). Osceola School District will not tolerate behavior by students or staff which ”insults, degrades, or stereotypes any race, gender, disability, physical condition, ethnic group, religion, sexual orientation”. Palm Beach County has extensive, vivid behavioral regulations regarding anti-gay actions, whether verbal or physical.

Stemming from a Supreme Court ruling, codes of conduct are in every school district. They’ve grown from pamphlet-sized delineations of simple infractions and consequences, to quasi legal booklets with dozens of pages informing the school community of rights, responsibilities, expectations, as well as infractions and consequences.

Broward County’s Discipline Code has an aggressive approach to  students’ wellbeing. A full page on human trafficking discusses sexual exploitation, explaining LGBTQ+ is especially vulnerable. According to the BCDC, Florida ranks third in sex trafficking among states, which attests to why some districts are concerned about high-risk populations.    Also, the Broward Code expressly forbids (pg. 18):

Harassing others because of age, color, gender, gender identity, gender expression, national origin, marital status, race, religion, or sexual orientation.”

 Bullying a student for gender expression is no different than harassing someone for race or religion; everyone’s case will be treated equally. Since all students receive or can access the district guide online, Broward—and other Florida districts expressing similar policies—violate Don’t Say Gay (DSG) as soon as they distribute the behavioral rules.

Broward County’s code also states curriculum policy in the general area of family and personal health (p. xvii). K-3 includes lessons on feelings, positive self-image, staying healthy. Grades 4-5 discuss puberty, HIV, friendship, self-esteem; grades 6-8 covers abstinence, decision making, HIV. High Schools teach about abstinence, risk, exploitation, health.

 Teaching is about asking questions, providing answers, showing choices, pointing ways forward—helping kids understand. This applies across the K-12 curriculum. Although prohibition lessens to “age and developmentally appropriate”  after grade 3, primarily because “age and developmentally appropriate” interpretations have been wrested from educators and co-opted by politicians. Under  DSG, teachers and deans will either break the law or their professional responsibility. Kansas and Ohio are considering similar legislation as Florida’s. The chilling effect for teachers across the country will be more like an Ice Age, as every breath vaporizes with potential disciplinary or legal action regarding any utterance about LGBTQ+.

 Activist parents and crusaders see themselves as good soldiers in the culture wars. They could demand random visits to classrooms; tell their children to record or video a teacher; Ask a child what the teachers discussed in class; give instructions to write  down and report back anything on the subject. Inquiries like these go beyond the normal parental questioning, weaponizing kids, who like nothing more than getting a teacher in trouble.

Besides classroom instruction, other services support the educational environment, such as guidance counselors, school psychologists, social workers, and the disciplinary agents. They all have a kite-string thin tightrope to walk, especially deans.  While not a classroom per se, these support offices may be construed as a classroom and the communication with the students as instructive.

These vital interactions in discipline cases inherently contain serious discourse about gender identity or homosexuality. Based on this, counseling the victim and dealing with the perpetrator will automatically place the school officials in the crosshairs of DSG.  These incidents cannot be resolved without professional responsibilities and the new law being in abject conflict.

Students accused of conduct infractions are entitled to due process. An investigation ensues, followed by such measures as guidance, counseling, discussion, and restorative sessions, as well as more severe consequences. It is impossible to discuss an LGBTQ+  incident without talking about gay or gender expression. Any lawyer worth his shingle will have no problem proving a K-3 violation or the “age and developmentally appropriate” clause. It only takes one sentence in a forty-minute conference with a student to find violations of the law’s standards.

Florida’s new educational waters ring the buoys’ alarm bells, as  potential sacrifices—teacher and LGBTQ student both--dangle defenselessly, holding their breath in fear and uncertainty, like so many baby seals in the heated water.

 Maybe that’s the whole idea of Governor DeSantis’ most dangerous gayme.

 

THEY LEFT THEIR SEATS IN SAN FRANCISCO.

Three SFSB members went a school too far, as the far Left progressive trio were recalled and ousted from the city by the bay’s school board. They died of self-inflicted wounds, impaled on the radical spike of far left activism.  

 The school-renaming movement built momentum as a reform to stop honoring Confederate figures. Given where we are in the 21st Century, it’s  a reasonable project whose time had come. The train derailed when the hit list went after time-honored Americans—usually dead white males— replacing them with progressive icons and symbols of its unofficial platform.

 Wiping out George Washington, revolutionary war legends, Abraham Lincoln, and others in favor of politically correct heroes appalled even the tres, tres liberals of San Francisco. Many recognized the immense damage to the national culture, and educational implications of equating Abraham Lincoln to Jefferson Davis. In addition to our native population, we have a huge immigrant demographic with little knowledge of their new country’s past. Denigrating revered Americans and banishing their names to skewed pedantic politics weakens the national character by disavowing the best of our historical icons. Cancelling members of the American pantheon is oxymoronic to inclusion. We can cherish our noble past, discuss our mistakes and failures while exploring the zeitgeist in which it all unfolded, and move forward to a more perfect Union.

 Incidentally, I doubt very much the new names would meet the SF3’s own standards of saintly perfection, an unblemished life without error, unstigmatized by prejudice. The progressive Left has their own issues with bias and inclusion. However, their objective transcends mere nomenclature.

 Among the first acts of attaining power, revolutionaries will destroy the manifestations of the past because legitimizing the new regime is critical to solidifying power. Name replacement is about supplanting traditional American beliefs and shared homage to our democratic heritage with Far Left progressivism. The Right is doing the same when they control the school boards. We see it in the anti-democratic book censorship in schools and support of anti-anti-bullying programs. school boards disrespect our democracy by denying or repelling any social and cultural advancements made since 1960 or name change for partisan advantage . The victim of both extremes is our national identity, common cause, shared reverence for imperfect humans who rose to be great when needed the most. Our students and country suffer when revisionist politics turn heroes to outliers.                                                                                                                                                                    .

A case in point: the SF Board placed Dianne Feinstein Elementary School    in the crosshairs of the Name Police. The Left’s beef with the former mayor rewinds to a 1984 incident, wherein then Mayor Feinstein replaced a Confederate flag, torn down by activists. In addition to this incident, local media has reported her centrist views has drawn their ire for decades. Canceling Feinstein would be a major moral victory for progressives, despite her minority status as a  woman and—or because of it—an octogenarian Jew. Feinstein’s erasure smacks of the radical Democratic socialists’ own partisan aims and prejudices that infuriated the rest of San Francisco.

 While the trio lost their way in the name game, the school system and its communities of students, staff, parents,  was free falling. The mayor saw “a political agenda” supersede their management obligations. The members also strove to eliminate requirements for its elite high school—a flashpoint for hard progressive leftists that also carried anti-Asian connotations. Accusations over COVID19 miscues was the last straw.

 The city’s mayor, London Breed, summed it up when he said the school board was distracted by “political agendas. “ (Newsmax).  Mayor Breed got one thing wrong: the political agenda was not a distraction. It was the raison d etre.

Cutting Student's Hair Not in the Job Specs

In Michigan, a teacher cut a seven-year-old girl’s hair. A student had snipped the girl’s locks days earlier,  leaving her head with a very uneven look. Taking the girl’s plight to heart, the teacher released her inner coiffeur and tried to compensate for the tonsorial damage.

However, she never spoke to her parents about restoring the imbalance. WHAT?! I’m not sure what her intentions were, be they maternal or underlying, but most teachers know not to violate a student’s person. The teacher might have asked the girl, but seven is not the age of consent for anything. You don’t cut hair, clip fingernails, paint toenails, pierce ears, or otherwise alter kids’ bodies. You can’t even put a hand on a student’s shoulder these days.

She and just about everybody in the district is being sued by her parents. Two other teachers knew of the incident but never reported it. They are now in hot water for not coming forward.  Let’s hope the school interviews the student who originally did the cutting and find out what’s going on there. This could require student disciplinary action, guidance counseling, or some intervention to ensure the well being of the student perp and the victim. Not to mention the adult.

I’m curious to find out how the school managed the original incident. There seems to be a scarcity of reporting on that, but such incidents could be indicative of issues deeper than a youngster’s prank, such as a hostile relationship or friendship gone sour. That’s why a thorough, multi-pronged approach is necessary in such cases. We have student-on-student and teacher-on-student aspects  here.  It’s not just about the what, but the why and the what now. And that has long term  implications for all involved and the larger school community.

 

 

 

Virginia Dept of Education Forgets the Unforgettable

Some dates and days stand out in American history. They marshal the national spirit in a common bond, no matter how disparate our people. We celebrate July 4 for our independence; we mourn for lost soldiers on Memorial Day and pay tribute to all veterans on Nov 11. We know the Civil War ended in the Spring of 1865, as did Lincoln’s life by bullet.  Jan 6 now connotes when our Capitol was besieged by rioters and insurrection filled the air we breathed. Surprise attacks inflicting thousands of casualties come to the fore of our consciousness on Dec 7, 1941, a “day that will live in infamy.” 

Nothing stands in such stark relief to contemporary America as 9/11. Maybe because so many lived through it and so many died on it. Targets held no military significance, as did the Pearl Harbor surprise attack. Civilian planes turned into fuel-laden missiles with human shrapnel. It was terror yes, taking down the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center, nearly turning the Pentagon into a scrap heap, and a third plane pulverizing metal and bodies in a Pennsylvania field.

 It was transcendental. These were not armed soldiers in a field of battle or huddling in redoubts and forts. The several thousand dead were secretaries and stockbrokers, computer geeks and maintenance workers. They were everyday people going to work, earning a living, an aggregate of the diversity that perished on 9/11 because that is what America is everyday, before and since. The people who died and the buildings that were targeted precisely were blown up because they represented e pluribus unum—out of many, one; our buildings the economic and political might brought about by a democratic nation and a multicultural demographic. Bin Laden’s attack was, at its heart, mass murder against a political system he didn’t like, a culture that wasn’t his, a system needing to be defeated to impose his will for his goals and his ego. No one epitomized pathological bullying and mass murder more than the personification of Islamic jihad, a figure who now holds his own place in hell’s pantheon.

We have always faced our enemies squarely. We fought the Nazis not on a racial or religious bias but a political one. Although there was a racist component ot some of our war propaganda, we fought the Japanese because they bombed our territory and killed our people. In all the years since, we never flinched in who our foes were, and why we went to war. It was the Germans; it was the Japanese, and they were trying to kill us and our democracy. 

Twenty years after the worst attack on our homeland, twenty years commemorated year after year with the names of the dead read like a Georgian incantation at the Sacred Trough of Ground Zero, two rounds of silence at each plane’s time skewering the WTC buildings, and the reliving of private and public nightmares, personal anguish, charred lives of heroes still succumbing to their wounds; of men and women jumping 100 stories to escape the flames of death in one final defiant choice before falling.  

In one of the most disrespectful assaults on our country, our values, our defense, our freedoms, the Virginia Department of Education has striven to obfuscate the truth, pander to a political agenda, and betray its fundamental mission: to teach. In yet another attempt to suppress Americanism in America, the VDOE published a webinar for 9/11 professional development video for classroom lessons commemorating one of our most tragic days. Somehow, the disclaimer of “these views are solely that of the Dr.Decuir doesn’t quite it cut it.

The purported central objective of “Culturally Responsive and Inclusive 9/11 Commemoration” is to prevent and protect Muslim students from bullying, which Prof Decuir sees as the tragic result of the World Trade Center and other targets attacked that day. Decuir cites a troubling statistic—Muslim students are the second most bullied group in school. She doesn’t cite her source, nor does she name the first. I would imagine LGBTQ or Jewish students might head the dubious list, since statistics show gay youth ae subjected to harassment, ridicule taunts, physical and verbal abuse. Jewish students are now among the most threatened of all. I also tried an in an internet search to see what other kinds of bullying and harassment Prof. Decuir has written about, but I came up empty. Perhaps my poor Google skills failed to turn up a Decuir body of work on how to protect LGBTQ and Jewish students in our public schools from the actions Decuir says is aimed at Muslim kids.

No child should be harassed, threatened, bullied or otherwise feel unsafe during the school `day. Schools have strong discipline codes, which include violations pertaining to bias and discrimination under the umbrella of bullying.  Tweeners and adolescents have a strong mean streak compounded by numerous other teenage afflictions. Religion, ethnicity, physical appearance, jealousy—you name it, and kids will find ways to make you cry before you can get home and open the door. Schools do what they can with the resources they have and the authority given to guide youth in managing their conduct and social relationships in positive ways. Bullying has many definitions, explanations, approaches, to mitigating bullying. In a society valuing individual power, the job is significantly harder.

 What you don’t do is change history, suppress the truth, rewrite events, conjure fact into fiction.. If you are fighting bullying.  You must recognize the bully. Hijacking jets and turning them into missiles with human shrapnel targeting office buildings is the most malevolent, sadistic act of bullying—and war.

 

The video says “say what happened  and that’s the end of it”, according to reports. (The video was pulled from You Tube before TGBL could view it). Let’s teach what happened that day – a good lesson for our kids, those who teach them, and those who tell teachers how to teach. The Fire Department lost 344 members to Bin-Laden’s inferno; NYPD lost 71 officers that day, 74 law officers total. Many more suffered chronic or life ending afflictions. Many responders are still dying from their heroism to this day. 2,605 civilians who kissed their families goodbye, wished kids to have a good day at school, planned their work as they headed into the Trade Center, The Pentagon, or sat on Flight 93. All for the last time.

Yes,  the Virginia Department of Education, who promoted the video for 9/11 teacher training--let’s just say what happened happened. But that is far from “it.” Just talk to the victims” families, the responders relatives.  It is not “it” when residents and workers and students in the areas still suffer the physical and psychological effects of the day that changed America, and the world. To obfuscate  9/11 reality, to erase Islamic jihad’s Pearl Harbor in the guise of teacher development, to minimize America’s suffering and instruct how to suppress its pedagogy in the name of reducing bullying defiles the legacy of every victim, and violates every educational principle in a free society.

To borrow from Lawrence O’Donnell, Asra Nomani, president of Parents Defending Education, (quoted from the Daily Mail) has the last word:

“As an American Muslim parent and journalist who has investigated Islamic terrorism for the past 20 years, it’s offensive, immoral, unethical, manipulative and dangerous.”

 

 

 

Anti-Bullying Shot Down in Albuquerque

Three days into Albuquerque, New Mexico’s school year, a 13-yr-old boy is the first killed-in-school casualty.  Bennie Hargrove stood up to a bully and tried to get him to stop punching a smaller victim. The alleged perpetrator, Juan Saucedo, pumped multiple bullets into Hargrove and snuffed out his young life. The community has hailed Bennie a hero, a junior Good Samaritan who died trying to save a schoolmate in distress. As far as the incident goes, this appears to be the gist, and no more information has been released.

The terrible outcome blares out a warning that everyone involved in school safety, student behavior, and  anti-bullying for all to heed: The world is now a different place. Virtually all anti-bullying programs deride the passive onlookers or witnesses of a bullying scenario. Get involved, be proactive, intervene physically or verbally, provide information. Be the good citizen. The Hero. Be like Bennie.

 No one saw this coming, except for the reality-based educators experienced in student culture. Too many times deans and security APs heard the stories of threats, retribution, intimidation of witnesses and victims. It is a picture often pushed to the middle pages no one reads so the ugly, bloody schoolyards and cafeterias and hallways gain little attention compared to the marvelous work being done to make victim and perp meet on equal ground in the guidance office, a ticket out of math class.

How often students are told to be a good guy interventionist, be  an anti-bullying activist. Enlist in the  kindness brigade, do the right thing. The pipes, the pipes are calling, from school to school, and down the auditorium walls. Now the street angst of teenage life has claimed a victim because of naïve, courageous actions.  

Perhaps his intervention might have  been impelled by training, by altruism, by friendship, or a combination. We don’t know yet. Too much still lies in the deep background, the details of which must be gathered up and analyzed. What were the relationships, history; why did the shooter bring a gun to school. What set the wheels in motion that spun into a lunchtime murder at school lunch.

Too many anti-bullying approaches suffer the same fault as online financial business: it all sounds so convenient and miraculous, just  don’t ask about that security thing. It doesn’t serve the purpose at hand and may dampen the mood, so no negatives, please. Too many political activists (oh how we love activists) and professionals ignore the bare facts of adolescent reality because they just get in the way.

 We ask kids to be the soldiers in the anti-bullying army, give the recruits some boot camp for the kind and courageous,  then send them off to the front lines. And now we have a young teen gunned down by a boy the same age, alive yet all but dead. The authors, creators and pushers--school districts included--who construct  anti-bullying programs, school lessons, special presentations and its culture of therapeutic loquacity for violators and magnanimous fortitude for the brave  better go back to the drawing board and figure out how to protect kids who want to help. The shooter may be a bully and a  murderer, but the adults in the room have a lot to answer for.     

 

 

 

 

 

EIGHT JUDGES OUT: The Legal Assault on School Safety and Discipline Has a New Champion

Mos Eisley—You’ll never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy.                                           — Obi-Wan Kenobi

On a beautiful late June evening, the educational hives across the country were a buzzin’ late into the night. The growing number of education lawyers and their student clients--the misbehaved, oppositonals, the “dare ya” kids, the thieves, the bullies, the assaulters, the sociopaths and other EDPs who comprise the threat to a school’s community, raised their bottles and toasted the Supreme Court of the United States deep into the night and the wee hours of the morning. In particular, the man of the hour, 83-year-old Justice Stephen Breyer, writer of the majority opinion, was toasted more than marshmallows at summer camp.

Prompting the adulation was the 8-1 decision in favor of Brandi Levy over the Mahanoy School District. The somewhat ambiguous decision said that the schools cannot discipline students for off campus speech or expression. Except when they can.  SCOTUS, and this was an objection raised by Thomas’ dissent, did not elaborate on standards for intervention. They were very good at delineating the standard for non-intervention, but left it to the schools to decide on action for off campus behavior, using Breyer’s three point  guide, a piece of work on its own. TGBL looks at his three-armed monster below.

IN LOCO PARENTIS—I hate to tell the good judge, but no educator believes ILP even has a footing in the modern school, and young teachers[T1]  may know the phrase as a 3-point multiple choice question on a test in Education Administration 101. The constant judicial and political weathering of school authority has left ILP nothing more than an anachronism from a bygone era.  Many parents have been raised on weak schools, and their interference rather than collaboration has made ILP DOA. There is no ILP when kids are off campus, pontificated the judge.

Yes and no. ILP may be dead in the water, but schools are receptors for a student’s SOS. Come Monday morning, many middle school students will run to a guidance counselor, a dean, AP of Security with weekend,  off campus happenings--complaints, fears, or intel they hope will prevent a disaster, to themselves or others. Very often they are stories of domestic issues, bullying, threats, racist comments, personal anecdotes. Many of them sown in cyber,  in the park, the streets, the yard—for some kids the school is the only confidante. It may not be the narrow ILP of yore, but a child who feels trusting enough towards the school staff expects a level of protection, one he or she just lost. 

HEAVY BURDEN OF PROVE TO INTERVENE. There’s a famous analogy every political science major learns. The federal government is either a layer cake, with hard rigid lines of authority in relation to the states, as defined by the Constitution, laws, policy and precedent. Everyone knows the lay of the land. The second view is that it is more marble cake, with jurisdictions, policies, power, resources, authority executed on a more collaborative, blurry org chart, not without its friction.

When it comes to school discipline and its ecology,  Breyer has exposed himself as a layer cake in a marble-cake world. Certain school administration staff works with police, youth officers or SROs (NYC still can’t figure it out}, social agencies, mental and emotional health organizations, even religious leaders in the community to help students. Some situations that trigger such collaboration may not occur in schools. This ruling could hurt a school’s ability to assist in a child’s progress because behavioral issues off campus would now be off limits for fact-finding. While the Court said the schools have some leeway, no one will want to touch anything off campus for fear of lawsuits, which happen with more frequency than a kid “fuck you-ing” the school from the malls.

NURSERIES OF DEMOCRACY. WHAT?? Justice Breyer’s future on the court has been the subject of much speculation. Liberals fear his seat will be lost to another young right winger if he doesn’t resign, retire and give Biden a badly needed liberal voice on SCOTUS. After reading his opinion, he needs to retire…period. His 3rd piece of non-interference based on schools as free speech forums for students to express their political views free from school interference must have been written in his ivory tower before sending it to press.

Does he really think school administration gives a rat’s ass about what these kids say on their own time –or even in school—about politics, movies, dating, TV, fashion, or any other subject? Does he really think administrators fret over whether Johnny or Kim are cursing on their laptop from their bedrooms [T2] at 9:30 Saturday night? Kids will roll the entire gamut of obscenities and curses off their tongue before 4th period lunch.  The number of teachers called stupid, mother abusers, self-abuser, etc. will fill more pages than the New York Times archives.

Also, I am trying to discern from Breyer’s inestimable reason how disciplinarians will discover such political heresies, unpopular utterances, and yes…the curse words that dare not speak their names. Schools do not spy on their kids nor plant microchips in their innocent unsuspecting wrists to give a direct link to the surveillance office. Perhaps Breyer, while writing the majority opinion, experienced an inner John Nash moment while watching A Beautiful Mind.

No one cares, Judge. No one is listening. Schools do not hire staff to spy on students who don’t even talk politics except to repeat what they hear at home. Sex, drugs, rock and roll rather than the Greek Wars and nuclear energy still dominate the mouths of the roiling adolescent. To listen to Brandi Levi’s lawyers,  liberal phalanx, and the majority opinion, one gets the impression the schools could put the Russians to shame on domestic spying. Let me repeat to Justice Breyer: no one gives a damn what the students say out of school. How much they curse. Who they want to become president. Why they hate Trump or Biden. Or the Supreme Court. No one has the time, no one has the inclination, no one cares. End of story. Like current politicians pushing voter suppression laws in the guise of election integrity, Breyer provides an answer to a problem that doesn’t exist.

But here’s the rub. The bedrock issues relegated to the shadows  are school safety, discipline, and order. New York City for years operated under a simple premise. Yes, you have to show a strong connection between off-campus behavior and the school building, but any kind of activity threatening the welfare and stability of the campus ipso facto warrants investigation and possible disciplinary measures. If off-campus activity potentially endangers the school community, the dean and assistant principal now face a whole series of legal questions before they can even look into the problem or face accusations of First Amendment violations.  Let’s add one more item to the list of what keeps school safety officers up at night. Apparently,  the Supreme Court couldn’t give a rat’s ass about any of it. 

Maybe in Exeter or Phillips Academy or the Hunter School, places known for academics and upper class snobbery do these basic concerns  of the lesser advantaged public institutions fall on the back burner. Also, as private enterprises, they live by different rules from the plebeian abodes of most school children. But those vested with the safekeeping of public schools, especially in urban areas have no such luxury. Deans, Assistant Principals  of Security or Discipline, walk in to work Monday morning with worst case scenarios of a dozen incidents germinated on Friday running  through their minds like torpedoes. Did the ethnic slur turn into a schoolyard rumble; Did Sue continue her bullying online; Is Kim’s crush on another boy going viral when someone stole his phone and private, intimate messages were on there.

Not enough discussion was had about the safety implications of this decision, by the parties involved.  The majority opinion held schools do have a right to intervene in some off campus activity, but without offering an elegant, effete three-point standard. School officials will have to show linkage of in-school interaction that started the incident and off campus escalation. Yet that may not be enough,    Breyer covered his magnificent seven’s black-robed butts by stating the obvious in a vacuum

There were girls who were upset about the postings, and the cheerleader who made varsity could have easily been a target for retribution, if not from Brandi, maybe a friend, a boy trying to impress her.  What would the ruling be if violence or bullying followed? A disturbed adolescent among the 250 who received the posts might commit dangerous acts ins school. The court talked about severe bullying as a threshold to cross for off campus involvement but left it ambiguous. A simple “Fuck You”  can be severe if the consequences result in harm.  Sorry for your daughter’s injuries ma’am, but we were huddled up trying to figure what part of Breyer’s Triangle we could use to be proactive. We could not see the printouts because it was off campus, free speech, not during a school activity time. She is on her own.

The next school stabbing, shooting, assault or massacre will fall on school officials who decided they could not intervene because the situation was off campus and non-school related. He hung the staff who work in safety and discipline out to dry, and gave the lawyers a field day. Robert Hardaway wrote that, in a lawsuit against a school,  any good lawyer will try to knock down the good faith principle, another gem from SCOTUS past. Also, an equally serious charge is that the school did nothing when made aware of a situation. Now, SCOTUS applied the Gordian knot to resolving critical safety issues with this decision. Off campus issues were always a bit fuzzy, but there were ways to probe a potential exigency. These are now cutoff because talking to possible perps is now unconstitutional, as written record about the intervention and findings is a disciplinary action needed  to be filed. When as student’s head is busted or nose broken, parents and a panicky district want to know what the school did. It is legal protection that you did your job in good faith. Yes, if the assault happened in school, it could be dealt with. A workable case –did it start in school, did it start off campus, is it protected speech and does the school even have the right to intervene to determine that—may give way to staff, students, or visitors being harmed.     

“Tell them I came, that I kept my word”. So spoke the horseman in Walter de la Mare’s brilliant poem “The Listeners”.  At the heart of the intense work is a man committed, driven to ride alone to a house inhabited by phantoms just to declare his fealty to his honor, his word.  Maybe among  lawyers keeping your word of honor has lost its luster of integrity, but for young people it is one of the lessons without a grade, but whose mark lasts a lifetime.  Pledging to live by certain conditions to be on a team is also a vow to yourself. It builds character, teaches responsibility, holds you accountable. Living up to your word has more value than a bitcoin, as it sometimes forces self-sacrifice and hard choices, an ideal to achieve,  based on a promise to the whole of which you are a part. We like to think organized sports and competition shape the life for future productive and admirable behavior. Central to this concept is the teammates’ willingness to honor their commitment. There is a price to be paid when you breach the oath  taken, the contract on which you put your name, the deal you made with your team, your mates, yourself.     

This is what all the cheerleaders signed onto when they tried out for the squad. But Brandi Levy, her lawyers, parents and the Supreme Court held a different standard.  To the girls honoring their voluntary agreement to become cheerleaders, to Brandi Levy, who accepted the same terms of her own free will, and to students everywhere,  Breyer and his own oath-taking comrades on the Court taught a valuable lesson: don’t worry  about it, your word means nothing.  

 

 

 

Paxton Smith Goes Low at Highlands HS

At Texas’ Lake Highlands High School graduation, valedictorian Paxton Smith tore up her pre-approved speech and tore into Gov Abbott’s abortion law. The law’s intent clearly mitigates Roe v Wade, declaring Texas has the power to circumvent  the law of the land. Smith gave an emotional, sincerely felt personal monologue on her perceived consequences of the new law on women in general and herself in particular. Hilary Clinton, Sara Silverman, Beto O’Rourke have praise her courage to speak out and not remain silent.  

I confess my ambivalence. TGBL doesn’t care what political positions she takes. I don’t care if her audience fell over in shocked disbelief or stood on their chairs and cheered. Action Paxton has every right to hold her views and express them; however, First Amendment rights were not the only issues at play here. For one, she entered an agreement with the school. She submitted a speech for presentation, approved by administrators, then reneged and proffered a highly charged personal polemic without a word to the school that she withdrew her original speech. Whether she decided to change her remarks over breakfast or when she took center stage is irrelevant.

 Freedom of expression means you do not suffer consequences because of the opinions you made known publicly. It does not mean you can say anything, anywhere, anytime. There are considerations to a speech, such as audience, context, appropriateness. First rule is know your audience. Sometimes going off script is a good thing; sometimes it gets you in trouble. Not everyone wants to hear a teenager—no matter how smart or precocious—lecture a captive audience celebrating their children’s graduation rant about how she would handle a pregnancy in case of a rape under the new law. It is her right to feel exactly how she does, and her visceral reaction to a law she deems immoral is understandable. 

  By submitting the original speech to school officials, she agreed that that would be the one delivered.  It may be old fashioned and archaic, but keeping a commitment, honoring your word, especially in the context of a public event should mean something. She could’ve gone to her advisors and said this is my speech and I’m not changing it. If the school said no, then the backlash would be more than sufficient to get her word out. Confronting the school with her preferred talk would have been an act of courage too, handing the school tricky political and Constitutional questions.  I would have no qualms if Paxton announced at the end of her speech that she has a video on You Tube denouncing the law and trying to rally support. Call for a demonstration after graduation to fight the new legislation. Get airtime on the multiple media opportunities. An off-script  denouement would satisfy her agenda and still allow the valedictorian to claim she did not breach her agreement. To the officials’ credit, they let her continue and never pulled the mic.   

I wonder if all the Liberals praising her for her courage would feel the same sense of pride if Paxton delivered a speech exhorting states to recount the 2020 ballots so Trump can be installed as president and make Biden a one half-term president. Perhaps a valedictorian might stray from their script and explain why “Jews would not replace us” and ask for more Charlottevilles. Are such actions praiseworthy only when you agree with the views in the rebel student’s speech, or does all such activism merit such laudatory comments? We may not believe all opinions are value neutral, if the criterion is freedom of speech the student has a right to say it regardless of its repugnancy.

 It is all easy when you find the cause  in concert with your own beliefs, but  do you go full Voltaire and disagree but defend the student’s right to ditch the approved speech and go on a political rampage expressing abhorrent or offensive views. If such a right exists, it shouldn’t. Such conduct in other arenas would never be tolerated, and consequences would be swift if the organization was double crossed by an official who used it as an unauthorized political platform for personal  views.

 School is more than the sum of the academics it teaches.  There are subjects that receive no grades, but educate on responsibility, integrity, organizational relationships. The school board already announced a complete review of its process for student speeches to avoid a further situation. Paxton walks away a hero but made it that much more difficult for students to politicize speeches urging action. The students are not in charge of a school, and the weakening of rules, protocol, hierarchy, only hampers the functioning of a society already fractured and swollen with visions of individual power superseding vested authority.

 January 6 saw people express their opinions, hold the law in contempt, taking action. Admittedly Jan 6 takes it to the extreme, but individuals are not the law unto themselves, whether in a school, an organization, or a demonstration. Authority,  especially school’s, means very little these days, and the end result is what we see; ever increasing political violence, civics disintegration, social interactions turn into rage, mass shootings by the week. The lack of law and order begins with the courts’ evisceration of school discipline and its supporters. It worsens when public officials in statehouses and the Capitol condemn and discredit law enforcement, when Congressional subpoenas are laughed at; when a White House lawyer tells reporters to come get her for violating the Hatch Act. If respect for law means nothing to them, it would mean less to students. Evisceration of school discipline, already in high retreat, will only accelerate. Even now,  SCOTUS’ decision in Levy v. Mahanoy School District, sent school  safety to the back of the room with a dunce cap on its head.

 Freedom of speech and a podium to speak from are not instruments vesting students or protestors with divine right to nullify lawful authority—or betray your word and honor. Valid methods of activism and expression exist without breaking a school’s code of conduct or civil  law, whether you are a valedictorian, an aggrieved street demonstrator, or a believer in election conspiracies. There does exist circumstances in which such actions may be necessary. Graduation at Lake Highlands High School is not one of them.

 

 

BL Levy v Mahanoy SD: Hold on to Your Pom-Poms

    Back on June 30, The Third Circuit for the US Court of Appeals in Pennsylvania gave the judicial finger to school safety and student discipline by ruling in favor of a disgruntled 9th grade student who dropped a payload of F-bombs on her school using social media and received by 250 friends. The Court decided that she was on her own time, not participating in a school event, and using personal equipment. Therefore, she was free to open the hatch and let go the ordnance. The defendant, Mahanoy School District, appealed to the Supreme Court. The case piqued SCOTUS’ interest--oral arguments were heard late April. TGBL will weigh in further when a decision is rendered, which is coming shortly. For now, we’ll briefly look at a central premise of the 3rd Circuit Court’s opinion.

 Judge Krause, the majority-opinion writer, created an argument in a vacuum, a reality void, a piece perfect for second year law school, written in an ivory tower rivaling the height of a Dubai skyscraper. Krause said that the student’s behavior excluded threats and resulted in no disruption. No harm, no foul (except the bad language, which the kiddies use anyway, dontchoo know.) She quoted one of the education lawyer’s (you won’t believe how many there are) most lucrative mantras: the Justice Fortas’ oft-cited sentence from his opinion in the 1969 Supreme Court landmark decision on student speech, Tinker v des Moines, “It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.” What they do shed is the right to life and limb, skinned each day by the courts, leaving at the schoolhouse gate authority’s protective layer for their well-being in flagellated pieces. Flay and splay, a new judicial concept in school safety. The courts’ decades long assault on order and discipline may add Levy v. Mahanoy to its legacy of cases diminishing a school’s ability to maintain order and security. Lawyers at happy hour will raise a glass to SCOTUS if they hold for Levy, toasting a meddling court for driving new product to help an overcrowded field. Welcome to the world of education law.

 TGBL agrees no explicit, direct threat was made. However, interpretation of communication often requires inference. Threats, conspiracies, illegal plans, adolescent belligerence come in many cryptic forms. Apparently, only overt, literal statements are the guiding principals for the bright lights of the Quaker State’s 3rd Circuit. 

 In “Godfather III” at Michael Corleone’s Vatican award reception, a guest reached out to congratulate him. As he did so, he told Corleone someone in his district would be good for the courts. Michael said, “We could always use a good    judge.” The implication was clear: he has the power to make it happen by what means necessary.

 Michael Cohen, Trump’s consiglieri until he wasn’t, described how the former  president’s langue d’affaires was communicating in code. Dubious or nefarious, unethical or potentially illegal, the Big Boss’ instructions were encrypted in vague phrases and conveyed in orders cloudier than a London fog. You knew what he wanted done without telling you what he wanted done. As Boston’s legendary 19th  Century political boss Martin Lomasney said,  “Never write if you can speak; never speak if you can nod; never nod if you can wink”. Add former NYS Gov Eliot Spitzer’s corollary, “and never write an e-mail.”  People find ways to conceal true intentions and personal responsibility, ready to whip out the shield of “that’s not what I said, not what I meant, I was only kidding”. The Trojan horse lives today in linguistic and electronic iterations on a monitor, the mundane concealing the evil.

Kids have their own way of protecting themselves against accusations, no matter how delusional or wacky. A student will provoke another student by attacking the target with a shove, trip, whatever, and then beating him, claiming self-defense as the setup victim tried to recover. It’s a spinoff of the child who murders his parents and then asks for mercy because he is an orphan. Another trick is invoking the 1st Amendment to deny uttering the F-word: “I didn’t tell Mr. Smith to go fuck himself, I said go fuuuuhhh yourself”. See, no curse. Granted, the 3rd Circuit does understand in-school students shouldn’t curse out teachers, the administration, or school while participating or commenting on some aspect of  a campus’ multi-faceted schedule.

  So, fire away young stalwarts of the First Amendment, the courts have given you the playbook for being bad, some shady Roy Cohn legal advice on how to be illegal legally: Just don’t be direct in what you say, do it on a Saturday in your room, don’t nod if you can wink. Tell them you invoke the Krause Defense: ‘I’m frustrated’.

As we await the imminent Court’s ruling, teachers across the country can be heard repeating the words of Michael Corleone, “We can always use a good judge.”